Outrun Change

We need to learn quickly to keep up with the massive change around us so we don't get run over. We need to outrun change.

More followup on the Tesla Powerwall home battery

More comments on the nifty new battery for home use. Mentioned this earlier.

5/3 – Seeking Alpha – The Silliness of Tesla’s 10kWh Back-up Battery – Just a few silliness tidbits from the author’s long list of silliness factors:

  • Cost of $3,500 doubles to $7,140 with Solarcity’s installation package
  • Output capacity of the battery is 2 kw
  • Average modest home can easily draw 3 kw (i.e. would need 2 Powerwall to run an average home on an average day without a/c)
  • Central air conditioning for a medium-sized house draws 5kw
  • Even at 2kw, the battery would be dead in 5 hours – not much backup


Would need two just to power an average home on a mild day. Toss in any a/c, let alone a hot day, and you would require 4 batteries (5kw plus 3kw divided by 2kw). That assumes you don’t need a/c longer than about 5 hours and then can do without refrigeration and lights overnight. And I’m assuming you could put 4 batteries in series (or is it parallel?) so they are all online simultaneously.

Also read some discussion today that the battery is designed for 1,000 cycles at 70% drawdown.

I hope that doesn’t mean what I think it means. Will it even last 10 years if you can only draw it down to 70% up to 1,000 times? Only have 100 days of heavy use a year or the life is shortened? What am I missing? (Yes, yes, I know I’m showing my skills are in accounting.)

5/1 – Forbes – Why Tesla’s Powerwall Is Just Another Toy for Rich Green People – In an analysis that is way over my head, the installed cost of storage would be $0.15 kWh. Add that to what it costs to generate, which on a Solarcity lease starts at $0.15 and can increase 2.9% per year for the 20 year lease (uh, that means you are committed to paying Solarcity for 20 years? Wow.)

That brings the starting cost down to $0.30 kWh, which is um, astronomical.

What happens when technological revolutions drop the cost of installed panels by, oh, say, 75%? You could by paying nearly 20 cents a kWh when your neighbor installs a new system that only costs a nickel or three cents per kWh. Until the 20th year.

Article said it might take 8 Powerwall units to store enough electricity for a home and then struck out the comment. Don’t know how many the author thinks it would take to run a home, but the point is it would be multiple units. Three? Five?

5/4 – The Register – Tesla Powerwall: not much cheaper and also a bit wimpier than existing batteries – Ponder this as you consider how many Powerwalls you want to put on your Christmas list. One unit will provide 2 kW power.

That’s 2,000 watts at any moment. Here’s the consumption of a few home uses, per the article:

  • 1,500 watt – electric kettle
  • 950 watt – toaster
  • 1,200 watts – air conditioner
  • 2,400 watts – ironing for your wrinkled shirts

Unless you buy two units, you can do one of those things at a time. Do any two and you pop the circuit breaker. Actually, you can’t iron your shirts again. Well, if you want pressed shirts, I guess you could buy another $5,000 unit.

Author thinks a typical home would need 3 units.

Also, you can’t draw a battery to zero or it causes damage. So that means only around 70% of the 7 kWh battery would be available on a regular basis, or about 4.9 kWh.

That means adjusting all my previous calcs by only having 4.9 kWh available from each of the $3.5K list price / $7K installed batteries.

Single Post Navigation

3 thoughts on “More followup on the Tesla Powerwall home battery

  1. Pingback: Going off-grid. Would merely triple what I pay for electricity. | Outrun Change

  2. The Powerwall was originally announced with 2 kW power output with 3.3 kW peak, but Musk announced at the June 2015 Tesla shareholders meeting that this would be dramatically increased to 5 kW power output with 7 kW peak, with no increase in price. He also announced that Powerwall deliveries would be prioritized to partners who minimize the cost to the end user, with a total purchase and installation price of $4000.

    • Hi Phillip:

      Thanks for the info. That would supercede the comments both articles. Seems that would shift the analysis in each article. I think the underlying point that multiple batteries would be needed to power a home would still stand.

      Thanks for taking the time to comment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: